First, the easy way: PERRLA
Paste the article's DOI into PERRLA's reference search. When the publisher's record lists a retraction, PERRLA picks the kind A single retracted article, leaves the word RETRACTED off the front of the title, and shows a message that the article has been retracted, so you can decide whether you still want to cite it. Your Turabian notes and bibliography then show (retracted) after the title.
Before you save, check two things against the article itself. The search brings in only the year, so add the month of the issue (this Lancet article is from February 1998). And initials can arrive without their periods (A J instead of A. J.), so fix the authors' names to match the article.
Adding one by hand? Choose Journal, then Journal article, then the kind A single retracted article, and fill in the original article's details. The Retraction Information section feeds the APA and MLA formats. Turabian's notes don't print the notice's details, so you can leave it blank if you only need Turabian.
Not using PERRLA yet? Here is how to build the same bibliography entry by hand.
The parts of the bibliography entry
1. Author
In the bibliography, the first author's name is inverted: last name, a comma, then the first name and any middle initial as the article prints them. Every other author keeps normal order, with and before the last. List up to ten authors. With more than ten, Turabian lists the first seven, then et al. In a note, names are in normal order, and four or more authors shorten to the first author and et al.
Hunter, Janet, Karen Rawlings-Anderson, Tracy Lindsay, Tracey Bowden, and Leanne M. Aitken.
Some articles print their authors' first names as initials only, like the Wakefield paper below. Use what the article prints: A. J. Wakefield et al.
2. Article title and (retracted)
Put the article's original title in quotation marks, in title case. Then add (retracted) in parentheses after the closing quotation mark. In the bibliography a period follows it; in a note, a comma.
"Cardiovascular Disease, Drug Therapy, and Mortality in Covid-19" (retracted).
If the publisher's page now shows RETRACTED in front of the title, leave that word out of the title itself. It's a label the publisher added, not part of what the authors called the article.
3. Journal name, volume, and issue
The journal name goes in italics, followed by the volume number with no comma or label between them, then a comma and no. with the issue number. If the journal doesn't use issue numbers, go straight from the volume to the date. Leave off an initial The, so The Lancet becomes Lancet.
Lancet 351, no. 9103
4. Date
Put the date of the issue the article first appeared in, in parentheses: the month, if the journal gives one, and the year. Use the year the article came out, not the year it was retracted.
(February 1998)
5. Pages or article number
After the date, add a colon and the article's full page range in the bibliography, or the page you cited in a note. Online journals that number articles instead of pages get the article number in that spot.
: 637–41.
: e102.
6. DOI
End with the original article's DOI as a https://doi.org/ link, not the DOI of the retraction notice. With no DOI, give the database name or a stable URL instead.
https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2007621.
Examples
The Wakefield MMR article in The Lancet
The 1998 case series that set off the MMR vaccine scare, published in The Lancet's February 28, 1998, issue and fully retracted by the journal in 2010. It has 13 authors, so the notes use the first author and et al. In the bibliography, Turabian lists the first seven and then et al.
Bibliography
Wakefield, A. J., S. H. Murch, A. Anthony, J. Linnell, D. M. Casson, M. Malik, M. Berelowitz, et al. "Ileal-Lymphoid-Nodular Hyperplasia, Non-specific Colitis, and Pervasive Developmental Disorder in Children" (retracted). Lancet 351, no. 9103 (February 1998): 637–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(97)11096-0.
- First footnoteA. J. Wakefield et al., "Ileal-Lymphoid-Nodular Hyperplasia, Non-specific Colitis, and Pervasive Developmental Disorder in Children" (retracted), Lancet 351, no. 9103 (February 1998): 637, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(97)11096-0.
- Shortened noteWakefield et al., "Ileal-Lymphoid-Nodular Hyperplasia," 637.
A retracted article with an article number
A 2020 New England Journal of Medicine study of COVID-19 patients, retracted by its own authors within weeks because they couldn't verify the data it was built on. The article is numbered e102 instead of having pages, so the article number takes the pages' place and the note has no page to cite.
Bibliography
Mehra, Mandeep R., Sapan S. Desai, SreyRam Kuy, Timothy D. Henry, and Amit N. Patel. "Cardiovascular Disease, Drug Therapy, and Mortality in Covid-19" (retracted). New England Journal of Medicine 382, no. 25 (June 2020): e102. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2007621.
- First footnoteMandeep R. Mehra et al., "Cardiovascular Disease, Drug Therapy, and Mortality in Covid-19" (retracted), New England Journal of Medicine 382, no. 25 (June 2020), e102, https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2007621.
- Shortened noteMehra et al., "Cardiovascular Disease."
A nursing education article retracted years later
A June 2018 Nurse Education Today study, retracted in the journal's January 2023 volume. The journal doesn't use issue numbers, so the volume goes straight to the date. The date is still June 2018: a retraction never changes the original article's date.
Bibliography
Hunter, Janet, Karen Rawlings-Anderson, Tracy Lindsay, Tracey Bowden, and Leanne M. Aitken. "Exploring Student Nurses' Attitudes towards Those Who Are Obese and Whether These Attitudes Change Following a Simulated Activity" (retracted). Nurse Education Today 65 (June 2018): 225–31. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2018.03.013.
- First footnoteJanet Hunter et al., "Exploring Student Nurses' Attitudes towards Those Who Are Obese and Whether These Attitudes Change Following a Simulated Activity" (retracted), Nurse Education Today 65 (June 2018): 227, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2018.03.013.
- Shortened noteHunter et al., "Exploring Student Nurses' Attitudes," 227.
Footnotes
Turabian's notes-bibliography style cites sources in numbered footnotes. A superscript number goes at the end of the sentence or clause, after the punctuation, and the note with the same number goes at the bottom of the page.
- First note: the full citation, with the author's name in normal order, commas between the parts, (retracted) after the title, and the page you cited after the colon.
- Later notes: the author's last name, a short title in quotation marks, and the page: Hunter et al., "Exploring Student Nurses' Attitudes," 227.
- Four or more authors: the first author and et al. in every note, as all three examples here do.
- An article number and no page: the first note ends with the article number and the DOI, and the shortened note is just the names and the short title, with no page.
Make the retraction clear in your own sentence, too, since readers don't see the bibliography while they read: The retracted study by Wakefield and his colleagues claimed a link that later research did not find.
Citing the retraction notice itself, to explain why a paper was pulled? That's a separate source with its own author (often the journal's editors), title, and date, cited as its own journal item.
Common mistakes
- Mandeep R. Mehra et al., "RETRACTED: Cardiovascular Disease, Drug Therapy, and Mortality in Covid-19,"Mandeep R. Mehra et al., "Cardiovascular Disease, Drug Therapy, and Mortality in Covid-19" (retracted),RETRACTED is a label the publisher stamps on its page, not part of the title. Give the title as the authors wrote it, then flag the retraction after it.
- Nurse Education Today 65 (2023): 227Nurse Education Today 65 (June 2018): 227The date is the date of the issue the article first appeared in. The year of the retraction doesn't replace it.
- Lancet 351, no. 9103 (February 1998): 637–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(97)11096-0 (Retraction published 2010, The Lancet, 375[9713], 445)Lancet 351, no. 9103 (February 1998): 637–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(97)11096-0.The retraction note in parentheses is APA's format. Turabian has no retraction note, so the entry ends with the DOI, and the title carries the (retracted) flag.
- Wakefield et al. showed that the MMR vaccine is linked to autism.1Wakefield et al.'s retracted 1998 study claimed a link between the MMR vaccine and autism.1A footnote alone doesn't tell your reader the work was pulled. Say so in your sentence, and never present a retracted finding as established.
- Mehra, Mandeep R., et al. "Cardiovascular Disease …"Mehra, Mandeep R., Sapan S. Desai, SreyRam Kuy, Timothy D. Henry, and Amit N. Patel.The bibliography lists up to ten authors. Et al. belongs in the notes, for four or more authors.
Quick checklist
- The article's original title, with RETRACTED left off
- (retracted) right after the title, in the note and the bibliography
- The original issue's date, not the retraction's
- Notes: names in normal order, et al. for four or more
- Bibliography: first author inverted, up to ten authors
- The original article's DOI, not the notice's
- The retraction named in your own sentence, too
Questions students ask
Can I cite a retracted article in a Turabian paper?
Yes, when the retraction is part of your point: a paper on research ethics, on the history of a debate, or on how a claim spread. Don't cite a retracted study as evidence for a finding. If you're not sure, ask your instructor.
Does Turabian have a special format for retracted articles?
No. Neither the Turabian manual nor The Chicago Manual of Style (17th ed.) sets a format for citing a retracted article, so you cite it as a regular journal article. PERRLA adds (retracted) after the title so the flag shows in your notes and bibliography, and you should also say it in your sentence.
Which date do I use, the article's or the retraction's?
The article's. Give the month and year of the issue it was first published in. The retraction notice's date belongs only in a citation of the notice itself.
Do I need to cite the retraction notice too?
Only if you use it, for example to explain why the paper was pulled. Then the notice is a source of its own, with its own author (often the editors), title, journal, and date, in its own note and its own bibliography entry.
How do I find out whether an article was retracted?
Check the article's page on the publisher's site, which usually shows a retraction banner, and its PubMed record, which links to the notice under Retraction in. PERRLA's reference search also tells you when the record it finds lists a retraction.
Related guides
Rules checked against Kate L. Turabian's A Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations (9th ed.), chapters 16 and 17, the Turabian Citation Quick Guide, and The Chicago Manual of Style (17th ed.), chapter 14 (14.76 for works with more than ten authors) and chapter 8 (headline-style capitalization), with Turabian 22.3 (headline style, hyphenated compounds, and the initial The in periodical names). Neither manual sets a citation format for retracted articles: the CMOS 17 index lists retractions only under journal publishing (1.91). Example sources verified against PubMed (PMIDs 9500320, 32356626, and 29604606, with their Retraction in links) and each article's DOI.