Give PERRLA this holiday season, for every paper still ahead. Give PERRLA

PERRLA/Guides/Turabian 9/Poem, story, or essay in an anthology

How to Cite a Poem, Story, or Essay in an Anthology in Turabian 9

In Turabian 9, a poem, short story, or essay in an anthology is cited under the writer of the piece, not the editors. The bibliography entry gives the author (last name first), the piece's title in quotation marks, In and the anthology title in italics, a comma and edited by with the editors' names, the pages the piece fills, then the city, the publisher, the year, and the DOI if there is one. The first footnote uses in and ed., puts the place, publisher, and year in parentheses, and then gives the page you cited, followed by the DOI if there is one. Later notes shorten to the author's last name, a short title in quotation marks, and the page: Lorde, "Breast Cancer," 176.

The format

Last Name, First Name. "Title of the Piece." In Title of the Anthology, edited by First Name Last Name, page–page. City: Publisher, Year. https://doi.org/xxxx.

First, the easy way: PERRLA

In PERRLA, choose Anthology, then An entry in an anthology. For the kind, pick An entry in an anthology. Add the writer of the piece with the role Individual Author (person) and the anthology's editors with the role Editor. Then fill in the Entry Title, the Anthology Title, the Entry Page Numbers, the anthology's Publication Year, the publisher's Name and City from the title page or copyright page, and the DOI or URL.

PERRLA puts the piece's title in quotation marks and the anthology in italics, writes the full note the first time you cite the piece and the shortened note after, and builds your bibliography in alphabetical order. If the piece is much older than the anthology and you want to show it, type the year it first came out in Entry's Original Publication Year.

Not using PERRLA yet? Here is how to build the same bibliography entry by hand.

The parts of the bibliography entry

1. Author of the piece

Start with the person who wrote the poem, story, or essay, from the first page of the piece or the table of contents. The anthology's editors come later. In the bibliography, the name is inverted: last name, a comma, then the first name and any middle initial. In a note, it's in normal order.

Whitman, Walt.

Walt Whitman,

2. Title of the piece

Put the piece's title in quotation marks, in title case, never in italics. Italics are for the anthology. In the bibliography, a period goes inside the closing quotation mark. In a note, it's a comma. Use the title the anthology prints, without any note about where the piece came from.

"The Wound Dresser."

3. In and the anthology title

Write In before the anthology title in the bibliography, and lowercase in in a note. The anthology title goes in italics and title case, with its subtitle.

In A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology

4. Editors

After the anthology title, add a comma and the editors' names in normal order, first name first: edited by in the bibliography, lowercase, and ed. in a note. Ed. means edited by, so it stays ed. even with two editors, never eds.

ed. Robert Coles and Randy Testa

5. Pages

In the bibliography, the piece's full page range comes right after the editors, set off by a comma. For pages of 100 and up, Turabian accepts the full second number or a shortened one, so 174–179 and 174–79 are both right. PERRLA prints the full range here. In a note, give only the page you cited, after the parentheses.

Robert Coles and Randy Testa, 42–45.

6. Original year (optional)

Turabian doesn't require the year a reprinted piece first came out. Add it when the date matters to your paper, like a poem from 1865 in a 2002 anthology, and leave it out when it doesn't. It goes right after the piece's title, before in and the anthology: in parentheses in a note, and as its own short sentence in the bibliography.

Walt Whitman, "The Wound Dresser" (1865), in

Whitman, Walt. "The Wound Dresser." 1865. In

7. Place, publisher, and year

Give the anthology's city of publication, a colon, the publisher, a comma, and the anthology's copyright year, not the year the piece was written. Turabian 9 still asks for the city. Drop an initial The from the publisher's name. In a note, this group goes in parentheses.

New York: New Press, 2002.

8. DOI or URL

End with the piece's own DOI as a https://doi.org/ link, if it has one. With no DOI, give the URL of an online copy. A print anthology you read on paper ends after the year.

https://doi.org/10.1515/9781595587800-012.

Examples

A classic poem reprinted in an anthology

Walt Whitman's Civil War hospital poem, reprinted in a literary anthology for health care students and clinicians. It first appeared in Drum-Taps in 1865 under the title "The Dresser," according to the Walt Whitman Archive. This example adds that original year, since the poem is so much older than the 2002 anthology.

  • First footnoteWalt Whitman, "The Wound Dresser" (1865), in A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology, ed. Robert Coles and Randy Testa (New York: New Press, 2002), 43, https://doi.org/10.1515/9781595587800-012.
  • Shortened noteWhitman, "Wound Dresser," 43.

An essay taken from a book

Audre Lorde's essay "Breast Cancer: Power vs. Prosthesis," on choosing not to wear a breast prosthesis after her mastectomy. The anthology reprints it from The Cancer Journals, first published in 1980. It has its own title, so that title goes in quotation marks, and this example leaves the optional original year out.

  • First footnoteAudre Lorde, "Breast Cancer: Power vs. Prosthesis," in A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology, ed. Robert Coles and Randy Testa (New York: New Press, 2002), 176, https://doi.org/10.1515/9781595587800-037.
  • Shortened noteLorde, "Breast Cancer," 176.

An essay that first ran in a journal

Eric J. Cassel's essay on suffering first appeared in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1982, and the same anthology reprints it. Cite the version you read, in the anthology. Don't mix it up with his later book of the same title, published under the spelling Cassell.

  • First footnoteEric J. Cassel, "The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine," in A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology, ed. Robert Coles and Randy Testa (New York: New Press, 2002), 210, https://doi.org/10.1515/9781595587800-041.
  • Shortened noteCassel, "Nature of Suffering," 210.

Footnotes

Turabian's notes-bibliography style cites sources in numbered footnotes. A superscript number goes at the end of the sentence or clause, after the punctuation, and the note with the same number goes at the bottom of the page.

  • First note: the piece's author in normal order, the piece's title in quotation marks, in and the anthology title in italics, ed. and the editors, then the place, publisher, and year in parentheses, and the page you cited.
  • Later notes: the author's last name, a short title of up to four key words in quotation marks, and the page: Lorde, "Breast Cancer," 176. Leave off an initial A, An, or The in the short title. The editors and the anthology drop out.
  • Two or three authors: name them all in every note, joined by and.
  • Several pages: give the range you cited: 176–77.

Citing two pieces from the same anthology? Each piece gets its own notes and its own bibliography entry under its own author.

Common mistakes

  • Robert Coles and Randy Testa, eds., A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology (New York: New Press, 2002), 210.Eric J. Cassel, "The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine," in A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology, ed. Robert Coles and Randy Testa (New York: New Press, 2002), 210, https://doi.org/10.1515/9781595587800-041.You're quoting Cassel's essay, not the editors' work. When you quote one piece, the note starts with the piece's author, and the editors move after the anthology title.
  • Whitman, Walt. The Wound Dresser.Whitman, Walt. "The Wound Dresser."A poem, story, or essay is part of a larger work, so its title goes in quotation marks. Italics are for the anthology.
  • in A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology, eds. Robert Coles and Randy Testain A Life in Medicine: A Literary Anthology, ed. Robert Coles and Randy TestaAfter a title, ed. stands for edited by, so it's the same for one editor or several.
  • (Lorde, 1980/2002, p. 176)A footnote: Lorde, "Breast Cancer," 176.That's an APA in-text citation. Turabian's notes-bibliography style uses numbered footnotes, with no years in the shortened note.
  • "The Wound Dresser from Leaves of Grass.""The Wound Dresser."Give the piece's own title. A note the anthology or a database adds about where the piece came from isn't part of the title.

Quick checklist

  • Cited under the piece's author, not the editors
  • Piece's title in quotation marks, anthology in italics
  • Bibliography: In, the anthology, edited by, and the page range
  • Note: in, ed. and the editors, and the page you cited
  • City, colon, publisher, and the anthology's year
  • Original year only if it helps your reader
  • DOI as a https://doi.org/ link, if there is one

Questions students ask

Do I cite the anthology's editor or the author in Turabian?

The author of the piece you're quoting. The editors still appear, after the anthology title, but your notes and the bibliography entry start with the author. Cite the editors first only when you're citing the whole anthology or quoting their introduction.

Do I have to include the year the poem or essay was first published?

No. It's optional in Turabian. Add it when the piece is much older than the anthology and the date matters to your point, like an 1865 poem in a 2002 collection. It goes right after the piece's title: in parentheses in a note, "The Wound Dresser" (1865), and as its own sentence in the bibliography, "The Wound Dresser." 1865. If your sentence already says when the piece was written, you can leave it out of the citation.

How do I cite several pieces from the same anthology?

Give each piece its own notes and its own bibliography entry under its own author. If you also cite the anthology as a whole, like the editors' introduction, it gets an entry of its own under the editors. See our guide to citing a whole anthology.

What page numbers go in the note and the bibliography?

The note gives only the page you quoted or used. The bibliography entry gives the full range of pages the piece fills in the anthology, right after the editors' names.

What goes in the shortened note for a poem or story?

The author's last name, a short form of the piece's title in quotation marks, and the page. Use up to four key words from the title and leave off an initial A, An, or The. The anthology and the editors don't appear in the shortened note.

Rules checked against Kate L. Turabian's A Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations (9th ed.), chapters 16 and 17 (the original-year placement is 17.1.8.3) and 23.2.4 (inclusive page numbers), the Turabian Citation Quick Guide (its chapter or other part of an edited book example), and The Chicago Manual of Style (17th ed.), chapter 14. Example sources are the ones verified for the APA 7 and MLA 9 pages: each piece's Crossref DOI record (pages 42–45, 174–179, and 208–222; The New Press), the Library of Congress record of the anthology (LCCN 2001055827: New York, New Press, 2002, edited by Robert Coles and Randy Testa), PubMed (PMID 7057823: Cassel, New England Journal of Medicine, March 1982), the Walt Whitman Archive ("The Dresser" in Drum-Taps, 1865), and the 1865 first edition of Drum-Taps itself (the Internet Archive scan of Brigham Young University’s copy, which prints the poem as "The Dresser").

PERRLA writes the full note, the shortened note, and the bibliography entry for any piece in an anthology, under its own author.

Try PERRLA free for 7 days